Stocking Stuffers

Christmas orders will ship immediately based on product availability.
Skip to results list
21 items

Filter

  • Original Peanut Butter Meltaway® Novelties

    $11.95

  • Caramel Filled Kringles

    $11.95

  • Christmas Sandwich Cookies

    $11.95

  • Solid Chocolate Christmas Foiled Balls

    From $15.95

  • Happy Holidays Bar

    $3.80

  • Original Peanut Butter Meltaway® Santa

    $2.30

  • Santa

    $9.95

  • Snowman

    $7.40

  • Truck

    $6.35

  • Rudolph

    $5.10

  • Happy Santa

    $5.10

  • Christmas Tree

    $5.10

  • Holiday Snowman

    $4.00

  • Holly Bells

    $3.20

  • Stuffed Stocking

    $2.70

  • Poinsettia

    $2.70

  • Candy Cane

    $2.70

  • Jolly Santa

    $2.70

  • Happy Tree

    $2.70

  • Ginger Bread House

    $2.70

  • Gardners Original Peanut Butter Meltaway® St. Nick

    $8.50